Baptist Dysfunction #2

phariseesI was raised believing in the old BAPTIST
acrostic (below).¬†These are the things that supposedly made us ‘distinctive’ in our faith. But as I’m reading and learning, I’m discovering that most -if not all- of these do not mean what they used to… what they’re supposed to.¬†If you haven’t yet, you should catch up by reading Part 1 here. ¬†This post will focus on the Priesthood of the Believer & Individual Soul Liberty. (I’ve decided not to go in the order below, but to group them by their logical sequence.)

B- Biblical Authority
A- Autonomy of the Local Church
P- Priesthood of the Believer
T- Two Church Offices
I- Individual Soul Liberty
S- Saved & Baptized Church Membership
T- Two Church Ordinances

NOTE: Some readers of my last article noted that I write with an evident hurt buried deep inside. ¬†I can’t really identify one singular pain… but I do recognize certain ‘sore spots’ that are sensitive to me. This article, in particular, will really reveal a couple of issues that can affect my blood pressure in a negative way.

P – Priesthood of the Believer

The Bible teaches (1 Peter 2:5) that believers are priests, each having his/her own access to God. ¬†Since Jesus is our High Priest, we need no other mediator (1 Timothy 2:5). ¬†So why do so many IFB pastors stand in this role? ¬†Why do so many say things like: “Before you buy a home or change jobs, you should consult your Pastor.”? ¬†Why do they set themselves up as some kind of ‘priest’ that can divine and/or discern God’s will for the membership? I’ve heard preachers use a church member who didn’t get his advice as an illustration for foolishness or rebellion! I’m a firm believer in getting¬†counsel, but I also believe that Christians don’t need to ask their pastor for permission to buy a car! ¬†Then they take it a step further and take the initiative to assign standards for every family (what to wear, what to listen to, where not to go…), leaving little room for the Holy Spirit to convict. ¬†I believe our standards are far¬†too low & too many!

In addition, the IFB movement has become so governed by a ‘performance’ theology. We’ve lost touch with grace. Why do we continually allow our leaders to set the measurements for us? ¬†Doesn’t the Bible say that when we compare ourselves¬†by¬†and¬†with¬†ourselves we are not wise? Yet we continue to do it – we feed off of it, and it becomes a way of life. Read more about this here.

We define our spirituality by checklists of do’s and don’ts and we let other the fear of man dictate the lists. It’s more human¬†to call a suit & tie your church clothes than to really obey Colossians 3:12-14.¬†After all, it’s easier to measure the visible than the unseen.¬†I still do it (far more than I even realize)¬†and it is sin. The fear of man is a snare! For me, it took a long time to “find myself” after leaving the pretense¬†that I was under, in large part because I had always defined myself by another man’s opinion / approval.¬†It was a terrible mixture of my own insecurities fostered by the emphasis on performance by those surrounding me.

I – Individual Soul Liberty

Much of what defines IFB churches¬†are ‘standards.’ ¬†Unknowingly, churches are bound in the culture war more than they are in a war for doctrinal #oldpaths. In the 1950’s, when the Convention was going south (waffling on major fundamentals), a remnant of Biblicists separated from the whole and became Independent, Fundamental Baptists. ¬†In so doing, they became defined by their culture. Women wore skirts, churches used only hymns (with piano music) and black-bound King James Bibles, and preaching against ‘movie houses’ was common.

Examples abound… A pastor-friend was asked to leave his church in the 70’s because his son wore a white belt. ¬†I know a man who wouldn’t let his wife wear pantyhose because they were ‘split-legged.’¬†I heard about an addiction program which required all participants to wear proper attire. If they didn’t have any, they were provided with disposable plastic skirts (for the ladies) to wear during the class. ¬†No wonder it never got off the ground!

We have become so wrapped up in the externals. How refreshing would it be if we could go to a conference (IFB) and not to hear messages entrenched in legalistic manipulation. (Is Legalism a Bad Word?) ¬†We’ve used some Biblical words to justify our shallow preaching when — according to Jesus himself — there are far weightier matters to attend to!! ¬†The IFB movement is becoming known for its Pharisee-ism, and it doesn’t seem that much is being done to turn that around. ¬†That’s not the fringe, that’s the mainstream. And, thankfully, the younger generation of new fundamentalists are not willing to stand for some of these non-essentials or die in a culture war that their parents / grandparents started!

Romans 14 provides limits for Christians who are ‘strong’ in their faith as they help the ‘weaker.’ ¬†It clearly states (v5) that we need to let¬†every man to be fully convinced in his own mind. ¬†What that means is… Give people the space to come to their own conclusions and form their own convictions. ¬†I can hear it now… “But I’ve given them 3 months and he still hasn’t cut his hair. “Well that’s just crazy! Do you expect people to make up their own mind? What if they don’t decide to give up _________, what then? ¬†“I don’t think that she’ll stop wearing britches unless I talk to her about it.” ¬†I know, right!! ¬†Christian liberty is a dangerous thing. ¬†Sticky stuff here, folks. ¬†Which is precisely why we can’t get too far from¬†Matthew 7… the splinter & the plank.

Brothers, we’ve lost sight of grace and become lost in our religion that emphasizes fancy footwork and performance. ¬†Let’s get back to grace and leave the condemnation behind (Gal. 5:1). Just because you change doesn’t mean you’re compromising.¬†Jesus was hated because he was too far ‘left’ for the Fundamentalists of his day… so that puts you in good company!


Article by Patrick Nix


Other Articles  |  Bio

6 thoughts on “Baptist Dysfunction #2

  1. Great article…Patrick. The priesthood of the believer and “organized” religion are two subjects I have been thinking about lately. I would agree with you…except to say… this practice is not limited to the IFB…and it’s not limited to discerning the will of God for the church members. I would argue, that it’s a short distance from discerning the will of God for church members…and discerning the will of God for the entire church. Of course the mission of the church is simple…in short…spread the gospel to the ends of the earth. But within that mission their are countless ways to accomplish that goal…and therein lies endless room for divine inspiration. However, within the organization of the modern church, pastors set themselves up as a mediator between the church members role within the church…and the call of Holy Spirit on each of our lives. While most pastors would never admit this…nevertheless it’s an unwritten rule…members can’t be inspired by the Holy Spirit to lead or accomplish a task within the church…unless He(the Holy Spirit) first gets permission from the pastor or some other governing bodies within the church. I have even heard pastors argue that God only works through the pastor, then to elder/deacons/bishop, then to church staff and then to the church body…in that order. If that is the case, why would God waste His time talking to or inspiring the church member to accomplish anything within the church? Why not go straight to the pastor and let him convey God’s message to the rest of us? Uhmm….that has a familiar ring to it…something about the “Borg” and “assimilation”. Anyway…who wants to be nothing more than a tool others use to accomplish their divine hopes and dreams? After all, isn’t that what inspiration is…divine hopes and dreams? Knowing this to be the case, it is really hard to listen to the annual “get out of your pew” sermon. Who wants to step out of the pew, if they know doing so may mean a battle with the pastor or elder board? Unless of course you step out of the pew to help them accomplish their divine hopes and dreams…their way. Who wants to spend their life, their talents and resources trying to accomplish the vision God gave to someone else…while your hopes and dreams go by the way side? Shouldn’t we be trying to accomplish the vision God has given each of us? Or is it not possible that God could give each us divine hopes and dreams? Could it be possible that God wants us to accomplish the hopes and dreams He has given each of us within our local church? Could it be possible that God doesn’t want or need the permission of anyone to lead His people within His church? The older I get, the more I question the way we do church. I have come to believe, God works through His people…period. He doesn’t need the permission of the pastor or elder board to work through His people. He wants to work through those that are willing and according to the talents, skills and resources He has given them…regardless of their title or position within the church. I believe that a church that has set up a rigid “top down” hierarchy is simply missing out on many of God’s blessings.

    1. Tim that was a great response. We or me as baptist have to be careful about talking about what gifts The Lord gives us. We may become to charsmatic for the baptist church. Jkn ūüôā great read non the less. Bro (pastor) nix another great read my friend.

    2. Tim, Agreed! You’ve beat me to the punch … that’s coming in my next post! I really need the Lord to guide me into a proper balance in this. You know as well as I do that leadership can be quite a quagmire of slippery slopes and imbalances! Please pray that I will have wisdom as I lead what God has entrusted me with (family, ministry, etc.). Yes, there’s order in the church, but No, not like we see today in most churches. I find GP refreshing because of Pastor Bob’s humility and willingness to serve. You don’t find that as the norm. Thanks for your feedback – I appreciate your perspective!

  2. Great article! You have worded well the need for our churches to re-examine our course of action based upon what we claim to believe.

  3. Spent the morning reading Galatians and this post from you fits perfectly in Paul’s purpose in writing that letter. Well said, Patrick.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s